Bringing Europeans to the Moon

Year 2003, with recent tragedy of US space shuttle Columbia and with very likely launch of a manned spacecraft by China, is definitely closing an era of space conquest and opening a completely new one. The finishing era is the era of USA/Russia complete domination of space conquest ; the coming one is an era of multiple space powers without clear leadership anymore in terms of space conquest. In order to play an active role in that ‘New Space Order’, Europe has to rapidly define its strategy and to back it with relevant means. Otherwise, Europe will be left out of what will be, in any case, the new frontier for mankind by the end of this century.

Russia and the US cannot provide anymore the required leadership for space conquest

Russia’s space programme is today unable to address new challenges of its own. Crippled by lack of funds and no Russian political vision for its space assets, Russian space programme is indeed delivering robust tools and components, but no leadership and endeavour as during USSR time. Today, it is now obvious that US space programme is also in total jeopardy. Underfunded, based upon obsolete technologies and components, lacking also any US political vision for space conquest, it is today only the shadow of what it was in its leadership era of the 60s/70s.

China has a very ambitious space strategy

Meanwhile, in the past two decades, new space powers have emerged, mainly Europe and China (with smaller contenders such as India or Japan). China’s programme is obviously sponsored by a strong political will to use space conquest for reaching two main objectives :

1. establishing China as one of the very few space powers, commanding therefore entire segments of tomorrow’s technology and might

2. establishing Chinese as the people really serious about ‘going for the other planets’.

And as everywhere (but in Europe), China also uses its space programme to boost national identity and pride, projecting its own image into humanity’s future.

Europe is in need for a space strategy

Europe is the other emerging space power of the past decades. It has successfully taken over a major part of non military satellite launches and has therefore become the current leader of commercial use of space. It now faces difficulties which only occur to leaders : new technology development troubles (Ariane V repeated failures) … and the need for a decent long term strategy. Technology difficulties can only be overcome by better mana gement and funding. Both can only exist if there are clear political vision and will for a European Space Programme, heading towards 2050.

Audacious European space programme will bring Europe many benefits

Such a long term programme will bring several major benefits to Europe :

 insuring its position as one the major players of a key challenge of coming decades

 insuring its ability to be self dependant concerning the use of space (civil or military)

 developing new technologies with large fallouts in various science and technology fields

 keeping up with a future oriented image (as shown with the major impact in public opinion of successes like Ariane or Airbus), especially with younger generations

 generating a ‘European feeling’ of common identity and pride of taking actively part into a major human achievement : space conquest.

Let’s use future CAP savings to boost European Space Programme

Of course such a European Space Programme will have to obey several constraints in order to be successful (that is, generating the above mentioned benefits). First, it must define strategic objectives able to give Europeans a specific major aim, as well as being actively involved in other nations major projects. Simply said : Europe will have to be a leader in one of the key global project of tomorrow’s world space projects ; as well as taking part as partner in other major projects. Meanwhile, it must be funded and managed properly. Funds will be available from 2006 on as Common Agricultural Policy will decrease. Obviously it is out of question to reduce the already meagre EU budget ; therefore funds not anymore going to CAP will be available for other purposes : European Space Programme should be a significant one of the new funded policy. In terms of organization, the solution found for Galileo, a joint venture of both European Space Agency and EU, may offer a proper framework, at crossroads of intergovernmental and common policies.

Setting up a permanent European base on the Moon

The objective of being an active partner of all major international space programmes is already in place and must be pursued (International Space Station, Mars, …). It has to be widely debated on the contrary to choose which project should Europe makes its own. Fifteen years ago, when still a student, as president of AEGEE-EUROPE, I had several opportunities to discuss space policies issues, at the occasion of various ‘Space Week-Ends’ we organized in Toulouse and Munich with specialised students and with top European decision makers in aerospace. At that time one idea was being casted that Europe should focus on setting up a permanent base on the Moon (which was forgotten when USA and USSR where not anymore politically interested by the race to the Moon). Whether it is terms of science, seriously testing ‘industry in space’, finding new solutions to get rid of very dangerous pollutants, or even setting up a more adequate base for future exploration of other planets, the interest of such a ‘Europeans on the Moon’ space programme are numerous and concrete. This is only a possibility. But in any case, people only get interested by space odyssey if THEY (and not robots) are part of the game.

Manned space conquest is compulsory

Of course this require to send Europeans in space and to refocus the existing policy on manned spaceship. The recent accident of Columbia, and the fact the International Space Station, is currently unreachable for undetermined period of time illustrates how much it is important for Europeans to be self dependant regarding access to space (Chinese just know that and act consistently). Unmanned space conquest does of course has also its role and ‘niche’ ; but as far as we know, as Europeans, we did not explore the world by sending ‘drones’.

In a few years time, with the enlargement and its constitution, the European Union will be the youngest of all political entities on Earth. Being audacious and confronting the risks is part of being young. Trying by any means to avoid the unknown is on the contrary part of being old. If we bring Europeans to space, we will bring younger generations closer to feeling part of a common dream : a peaceful one, to be shared with the rest of mankind. And this time, we are sure at least that there are no inhabitants on the Moon, so we do not risk to commit genocide as we did in our past colonization adventures.